LoM2 - Day Four

[Kaden]

If his Warwick ability is the same, then he targeted her because that was the person he got information on (highest # of lynch votes on a day with no lynch) and she just happened to be mafia. What I still find kind of suspect is how Doe switched his lynch vote to Keiko at, basically, the last minute. If he hadn't done that, then Rose wouldn't have gotten any information (again, assuming the ability is the same as last game).

To answer Rose's question about my trap, my post just says it works on Night Abilities. There are Passive, Triggered, Day, and Night. Warwick's is an example of a passive, mine is Night, LeBlanc's was some combination of Passive and Triggered. So... there's a legitimate chance that my trap discovers nothing.

That said, though, the Trap (and I say this with 99% certainty, knowing Ashe) won't discriminate between a Night Ability that would be beneficial (a Doctor role, for example) and a Night Ability that would be detrimental (vigilante role). So, yeah, it's possible Nidalee was trying to do something helpful. Given, though, that we've already seen a savior role and two ability-stoppers (myself and Swain, if Rose is to be believed), I find it unlikely that he has an ability that's good for us.

Somewhat in Teemer's defense, I know he's been busy irl. That's part of why he hasn't posted much. So... take that for what you will.

Looking back through some of the previous days, I found this, which is now much more interesting:

I wonder if someone used a mass-negation ala Amumu last night. Warwick targeted me with something too and it also got negated.

Really? I was under the impression that Warwick's ability wasn't targetable as such, more something that allows you to get information on the person with the most lynch votes at the end of the day. I say that because I'm Warwick, and I smell bullshit.

And since she still hasn't posted, Lynch Keiko, the person I got information on and who was confirmed to be Swain, a mafia, whose ability allows her to stop a target's Night Phase action from working up to a total of twice. I was hoping she'd give some information before I let this drop, but I'd rather not wait until the night phase because I may well die before I get the chance to out a confirmed mafia. I was already targeted for Something by Shaco last night, though I still don't know if they're mafia or not. If I do die in the night, I'd suggest Rafael for the next lynch.

So someone here is lying. Either Rose isn't telling the truth about his ability (he claims it's a passive that he can't target during the Night) or Rafael isn't telling the truth about being targeted. Rose's case doesn't really make sense, since I don't see the point in trying to hide one facet of your ability when you've already disclosed a very dangerous one (dangerous to the mafia, that is); Rose could also have two completely separate abilities, but I find that scenario much less likely.

Rafael lying only makes sense if he was trying to direct suspicion towards Rose. Something to think about.

At this point... I'm inclined to give Rose the benefit of the doubt more than anyone else. At the very least, he ended up directing us towards a mafia lynch. I agree with him that lynching one of their own isn't a safe strategy with so few people in the game. I'm probably going to be casting a lynch vote towards Vad, but I would like to hear any reasoning he has for pointing the proverbial finger at Rafael and Tyr.

Unlike this post, there was no train of thought, just an accusation.