Chubbs Idol Finals Q&A - STAFF

[Super Buu]

Originally posted by Hellfighter 17
Please find three cases where warnings were given out (maybe even look for warnings that were given out before the clean slate if you remember 'em) and state why you disagree witht his ruling, and find three cases where a warning was not given out and you think it should have been and state your reasoning.

I hope that made sense.

Revoked Warnings:

Gokua

Gokua, IMO, did nothing to merit a warning in that thread. Especially since he was being flamed from all angles.

Dracula Man/Kilah

Whilst I probably would have loved to get him banned at that point, I still disagreed with the logic behind banning him (though he was un-banned later). Bear in mind that I'm not talking about the content of the thread (some of which was warn-worthy) but his being banned in the first place, and thus the event that spawned the creation of the thread. Advertising through Chubbs PM on one thing, but advertising your RPG on AIM shouldn't correllate to being banned on Chubbs. Perhaps I didn't get the whole story, but that's purely from what I saw.

Warnings not given out:

MC's deleted thread (obviously, there's no link).

The fact that it got deleted should have been proof enough that it was warn-worthy. It had a mature tag, the abuse of which was a 'no tolerance' policy the last time I checked. The fact that it was filled with pictures of dinosaurs having sex didn't help either.

Minoshia

Flaming.

Kirano

I believe he should have been banned at this point. It was his third warning, he was plagiarising and lying excessively to staff. Instead he just got a small warning. He started apologising as soon as he was proved to be lying, but up until that point he was insisting he was telling the truth, and disrespecting anyone that called it into question.


Only 2 for the first, because I can't recall any others I disagree with.